New York Parole System Called ‘Reincarceration Machine’

Print More
parole rally

Photo by Erik McGregor/Gotham Gazette.

New York State’s “broken” parole system costs taxpayers approximately $683 million a year to incarcerate people for technical parole violations, such as missing a court hearing, being out past curfew, or failing a drug test, according to the latest New Yorkers United For Justice (NYUJ) report.

 Now, officials have been clashing over proposed changes to the parole system as progressive New York Democrats push to enact reform before the end of the session. 

“New York’s parole system is broken,” said Alexander Horwitz, executive director of New Yorkers United For Justice, as quoted by the Adirondack Daily Enterprise.

“(It) does not serve its function, it does not do its job, it is expensive [and] racist.”

Horwitz noted that parole was originally conceived as a state-sponsored system of re-entry to bring people home from incarceration permanently and safely.

“Instead,” he said, “New York’s parole system is a reincarceration machine.”

With help from the Vera Institute of Justice 2019 averaged daily counts of individuals accused of parole violations, the NYUJ researchers used those numbers to estimate annual costs of incarceration. 

The latest report uncovered that New York State spends approximately $683 million of taxpayer dollars annually to incarcerate people for technical violations, while New York localities pay roughly half that staggering amount. 

Focusing in on New York City jails, the NYUJ researchers detail that there are roughly 738 individuals accused daily of parole violations. To that end, the annual cost of incarceration for one individual is $337,524 — resulting in an annual cost to incarcerate all the people for alleged technical parole violations at $249,092,712.

The numbers don’t change much when focusing on upstate localities either, the report details. 

At the Albany County Jail facility, NYUJ details that there are roughly 44 people who allegedly violate their parole daily. This in turn translates to an annual cost of $83,703 to incarcerate someone — resulting in a total annual cost of $3,682,932 for Albany taxpayers.

“Every stage of New York State’s parole system is incredibly costly, both economically and in terms of human lives,” Horwitz concludes in the NYUJ report. 

“Not only does the state’s parole system waste hundreds of millions of taxpayer dollars for the sake of unnecessary punishment, it routinely upends lives and families with no benefit to public safety or the well-being of justice-involved individuals.” 

Horwitz and the rest of the New Yorkers United for Justice urge lawmakers in Albany to prioritize system-wide parole reform to put an end to this “costly cycle of reincarceration.”

The full report can be accessed here.

TCR staff writer Andrea Cipriano prepared this summary.

3 thoughts on “New York Parole System Called ‘Reincarceration Machine’

  1. my fiancee was violated for driving a vehicle without a license [and] was also denied two good paying jobs because he would have to travel. he had his own business at the time and has never been violated for what he was first accused of doing in the first place .He is now [doing] 20 months for this. his business has been hurt and he has an elderly father he took care of. his parole officer violated him for something so little. the offense was dropped in court. [this post has been edited slightly for clarity]

  2. Absolutely a set up for failure. Beats logic to have such punitive measures and be productive in the society.

  3. We lost an apartment because my husbands parole officer was coming at the crack of dawn . Parking sideways in our driveway like swat and pounding on our bedroom window . The other tenant in the house was the homeowner .after this happened several times we were asked to move . It was hard enough finding an apartment on Long Island as it was. She said she pounds on window because our entrance was behind a fence . Just absolutely ridiculous. So unprofessional. My husband had a job after being put 45 days . He served 25 years. Perfect behavior in prison . Doing everything correctly . He had 6 different parole officers and never took the time to know him . Just where’s your paystubs is all they cared about . Thank god it’s over .

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *