Are Sheriffs’ ‘Deadbeat Dad’ Sweeps Worth the Effort?

Print More

It’s a monthly routine for sheriff’s deputies in Pennsylvania and New Jersey counties to fan out in overnight sweeps to capture parents who are in contempt of court for failing to either pay child support or appear for court hearings, or both, reports. Their names are published in press releases and local newspapers, and their perp walks are seen in evening news segments. Some are released the next day; others are held in jail for weeks or months. The raids reflect not only a nationwide ballooning of overdue child-support debt, which has increased by 1,000 percent since 1986, to a collective $114 billion, says the U.S. Office of Child Support Enforcement — but also a trend toward criminalization of debtors. One analysis in the journal Socius found 14 percent of child-support debtors end up in jail by the time their children are nine years old.

Sheriffs say sweeps are necessary to enforce payment orders and deter others from falling behind. However, the sweeps bring in only a small fraction of the debt owed. Five large New Jersey sweeps netted 1,567 people who owed $35 million in 2016 and 2017, but brought in an average of just $218 per person. Critics say that’s because many of those who don’t pay can’t afford to do so. They liken the situation to debtor’s prison, arguing that the cycle of arrests can be destabilizing, causing some men to lose their jobs and housing and fall further into debt. A 2007 Urban Institute study found 70 percent of debts in nine states were owed by people who reported annual income under $10,000. Montgomery County, Pa., Sheriff Sean Kilkenny said. “I was elected to protect public safety” and children are “my biggest priority. So I have no hesitation about doing these raids. Even if we don’t get the money back from these parents, it can act as a deterrent.”

One thought on “Are Sheriffs’ ‘Deadbeat Dad’ Sweeps Worth the Effort?

  1. The Montgomery County Sheriff has his priorities all confused when he says he doesn’t mind arresting so-called “deadbeat dads” because children are his biggest priority and arresting payors acts as a deterrent. Really??? What statistics does he have to prove this? Obviously none if they’re only collecting $218 per person per raid. The Sheriff needs to be removed from office because he doesn’t know what law enforcement is. Child support is a civil matter. The U.S. Supreme Court says there is NO probable cause that a crime is being committed in a civil matter. In fact, the Federal courts have all said child support is a common, civil debt. It’s not a special kind of debt. To the Montgomery County Sheriff: What part of UNCONSTITUTIONAL IMPRISONMENT FOR DEBT don’t you understand??? Stupid is, as stupid does.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.