U.S. Border Patrol agents have deliberately stepped in the path of cars apparently to justify shooting at the drivers and have fired in frustration at people throwing rocks from the Mexican side of the border, says an independent review reported by the Los Angeles Times of 67 cases that resulted in 19 deaths. The report by law enforcement experts criticized the Border Patrol for “lack of diligence” in investigating U.S. agents who fired their weapons. It said it was unclear whether the agency “consistently and thoroughly reviews” use-of-deadly-force incidents. U.S. Customs and Border Protection, which had commissioned the review, tried to prevent the scathing 21-page report from coming to light.
House and Senate oversight committees requested copies last fall but got only a summary that omitted the most controversial findings — that some border agents stood in front of moving vehicles as a pretext to open fire and that agents could have moved away from rock throwers instead of shooting at them. The agency’s internal response rejects the two major recommendations: barring border agents from shooting at vehicles unless its occupants are trying to kill them, and barring agents from shooting people who throw things that can’t cause serious physical injury. The response, marked “Law Enforcement Sensitive,” states that a ban on shooting at rock throwers “could create a more dangerous environment” because many agents operate “in rural or desolate areas, often alone, where concealment, cover and egress is not an option.” If drug smugglers knew border agents were not allowed to shoot at their vehicles, it argues, more drivers would try to run over agents.