Prosecutors Face Tough Decisions in Accidental Child Shootings


Three accidental child shootings in the St. Louis area in recent days have left prosecutors facing a delicate decision, says the St. Louis Post-Dispatch. In Missouri and Illinois, a parent can be charged if they knowingly or recklessly leave a firearm where a child can access it. It is up to a prosecutor to weigh the nuances of the case — including the age of the child, that child’s familiarity with guns, and the actions of the gun owner — to determine whether charges are warranted.

The decision is made against an emotionally charged backdrop, as with all accidental deaths. A quiet infant is left in a hot car by a distracted parent. A toddler runs toward a lake while his grandmother is inside talking on the phone. In each case, the potential defendant is already wrestling with their own punishment. “They’ve suffered a great loss already. To put them in prison — does that add insult to injury?” said Timothy Maher, a criminologist at the University of Missouri-St. Louis. “It’s a tough call for prosecutors.” In one case, 3-year-old Daniel Metz fatally shot himself with a handgun he found in his home. Daniel’s father, Maryland Heights police officer Ryan Metz, was one of the first to respond.

Comments are closed.


You have Free articles left this month.

Want access to all our reporting? Subscribe for unlimited access or login.