America’s Most Wanted Remembered for Dramatic Crime Re-Enactments


America’s Most Wanted, has been cancelled by the Fox network, will perhaps be best remembered for its dramatic re-enactments of crimes, says Slate. The program didn’t pioneer the technique. When the show came along in 1988, dramatic re-enactments had long been part of the legal and media toolbox. In some Asian countries, including South Korea and Japan, police treat re-enactments like perp walks. Criminals are forced to re-enact their crimes for the cops, who invite the media for maximum humiliation.

In the last 20 years, animation has replaced physical re-enactments in the courtroom. During the O.J. Simpson trial, the prosecution commissioned a detailed 3-D recreation of the murder. Gory details are allowed only to the extent they’re relevant to the case. Some lawyers consider reenactments prejudicial no matter what. Say a jury first watches the prosecution’s fancy 3-D animation of the alleged crime, then hears the defense’s verbal account. “What’s gonna stick in their mind is the snazzy video recreation,” says Mark Godsey, a law professor at the University of Cincinnati and a former federal prosecutor. America’s Most Wanted combined the entertainment and legal value of re-enactments. Its dramatic recreations may have exploited the audience’s emotions, but with the goal of catching the perpetrator. Police and the FBI cooperated in creating the re-enactments, which produced results. “It’s a remarkable record,” President Obama said of the show’s role in apprehending more than 1,000 suspects.

Comments are closed.


You have Free articles left this month.

Want access to all our reporting? Subscribe for unlimited access or login.