OH Vows Review Of DNA-Sample Processing After Contamination Reports


The head of Ohio’s state crime lab is promising a “top to bottom” review of the way its technicians process DNA samples, reports WBNS10-TV in Columbus. Thomas Stickrath, new superintendent of the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Identification & Investigation, which operates the lab, says evidence in some recent cases might have been mishandled. “I think folks could have been more careful,” Stickrath told WBNS-TV (Channel 10). Yesterday, the TV station reported on its investigation that turned up dozens of cases in which DNA evidence was contaminated while in the lab’s possession – sometimes, it appears, with DNA from technicians who handled the samples.

Lab officials acknowledge some contamination but downplay its significance. In the past four years, the lab identified 46 instances in which a batch of DNA was contaminated, said Liz Benzinger, DNA quality-assurance administrator for the bureau. The affected DNA had a potential bearing on 106 cases. During that time, the lab tested 28,618 samples, so contamination occurred in about 1 percent of the cases. “Even if it happens only once a year, that’s something that really needs to be remedied,” said Dan Krane, a biological-sciences professor at Wright State University and founder of Forensic Bioinformatics, which reviews DNA test results from hundreds of court cases around the world each year.

Comments are closed.


You have Free articles left this month.

Want access to all our reporting? Subscribe for unlimited access or login.