PA Case Shows Power Of DNA Felon Database


In 1998, a woman returning home from a church event near Philadelphia was grabbed from behind and raped. She could describe the man only as having a baritone voice and breath that smelled of alcohol, says the Philadelphia Inquirer. For seven years, the crime went unsolved. Then Pennsylvania required anyone convicted of a felony to have their DNA recorded in a database, deluging the state police crime lab with more than 40,000 DNA samples. One turned out to be from a convicted forger, William McKannan, 43. McKannan had no record as a violent criminal and was never considered a suspect in the 1998 crime. But his DNA matched the DNA from semen on the victim’s clothes. McKannan was arrested and is now in jail awaiting trial.

McKannan’s arrest is a harbinger of things to come. An FBI database linking all 50 states already contains the DNA of almost 1 percent of all Americans, or 2.7 million people. It has proved a useful tool for law enforcement; in Pennsylvania alone police use DNA analyses in a dozen cases a month. Civil libertarians worry that the nation is requiring ever larger numbers of people to submit genentic information even without a criminal conviction. By 2009, California will require DNA testing of every person arrested on a felony charge – not just convicted of one – a step toward making DNA records as common as fingerprints in law-enforcement files. That’s already done in Louisiana, Texas, and Virginia. Forty-three states, including New Jersey, have laws requiring convicted felons to submit their DNA.


Comments are closed.


You have Free articles left this month.

Want access to all our reporting? Subscribe for unlimited access or login.